Comparison

Clover vs Square for restaurants

Orqestra connects to both, so we have no reason to push you either way. This page is what we tell owners who ask: where each POS is stronger for a counter-service or small full-service restaurant, and what you will still need alongside it.

Short version: Square is the easier self-serve start (free software tier, sign up online, transparent per-swipe rates) and its Square for Restaurants tier covers most small full-service needs. Clover is sold through banks and resellers, so the processing rate is negotiated and the hardware is leased or bought up front, but its App Market and merchant API give back-office apps deeper, cleaner access. Both report sales; neither gives you prime cost, ingredient inventory or a cash-flow view, which is where a back-office app comes in.

How you buy them

CloverSquare
Who sells itFiserv through banks (Bank of America, Wells Fargo, PNC and others) and independent resellersSquare directly, online
Processing rateNegotiated with the reseller; varies widelyPublished flat rates per transaction type
Software plansTiered monthly plans per device, set by the resellerFree tier, plus Square for Restaurants paid tiers
HardwareClover Station, Mini, Flex, Kiosk; bought or leasedSquare Register, Terminal, Stand, Reader; bought
ContractDepends on the reseller; read the term and the early termination clauseMonth to month

Rates and plan names change; check both vendors' current pages before deciding. We do not list prices here because they would be out of date in a quarter.

Restaurant features

NeedCloverSquare
Table and course managementThrough Clover Dining on Station or FlexSquare for Restaurants (paid tier)
Kitchen displayClover KDSSquare KDS
Online orderingClover Online Ordering, commission-freeSquare Online, commission-free, with a free site
Tips and tip poolingYesYes, with Team management
Employees and shiftsYes (Shifts app); some reports need the Employees permission for appsYes (Team, Timecards)
InventoryItem stock counts; no ingredients or recipesItem stock counts; ingredient inventory needs an add-on
ReportingSales, items, tenders, employees; exportsSales, items, categories, team; exports; good dashboards

Apps and integrations

This is where they differ most for a back-office app like ours. Clover has an App Market where a merchant installs an app and grants it permissions, plus a merchant API token path that works today without a listing. Orders, tenders, items, customers and employees are all readable, and webhooks tell us about changes within a couple of minutes. Square has a self-serve developer platform with OAuth and webhooks; connecting is just as quick, but Square's orders model is per location, so a seller with several locations connects each one separately.

Both work with Orqestra. The Clover connection is the one most of our customers use; Square and Toast connections are in early access.

Who should pick what

If you areLean towardsBecause
Opening a counter-service place and want to be live this weekSquareSign up online, flat rates, free software tier, free online ordering site
Already banking with a Clover reseller who gives a good rateCloverA negotiated rate on real volume can beat flat rates; the hardware is solid
Full service with courses, seats and a barEither; compare Clover Dining with Square for Restaurants in a demoBoth cover it; the difference is the hardware you prefer at the table
Running several locations under one ownerClover or Square plus a back officeNeither gives cross-location P&L; Orqestra's Enterprise plan does
Watching food cost and labor closelyEither, plus a back-office appPrime cost, recipe inventory and cash flow are not POS features

What neither will do for you

  • A P&L with prime cost (food plus labor as a share of sales).
  • Ingredient inventory that depletes from recipes, counts with variance and purchase orders.
  • Bills with due dates, recurring expenses and a cash-flow forecast.
  • TV menu boards that follow the POS menu without a signage subscription.
  • A website whose menu stays in sync with the POS.

That list is what Orqestra's features cover, on top of whichever POS you choose.

Questions

Can I move from Clover to Square (or back) later?

Yes. Menu items export from both. Order history does not transfer between them, so keep a copy of your reports or a back-office app that holds the history.

Which is cheaper?

For a small shop with low volume, Square's flat rates usually are. Above a few hundred thousand dollars a year in card sales, a negotiated Clover rate can be lower. Ask for the effective rate in writing either way.

Does Orqestra need a specific plan on either?

No. Any Clover plan with web dashboard access, or any Square account, is enough to connect.

See it with your own numbers

Request access, connect Clover in a minute, and your first reports are ready after the first sync. No card needed.